Felt or straw? That’s the question every western hat fan asks as soon as you’re thinking about buying a second one. The answer depends first and foremost on the season and how you plan to wear it. Each material has its strengths, its limits, and its cultural codes. Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right one.
(Find all our tips in our cowboy boots buying guide.)The felt cowboy hat: fall, winter, indoors
Felt is the historic material of the western hat. It holds its shape, handles moderate moisture, and ages with character. It’s the hat of tradition, indoor country concerts, and western nights in the fall.
Check out our complete guide: How to choose a cowboy hat: shape, material, and size.
Its advantages :
- Excellent shape retention - a well-cared-for felt hat keeps its crown intact for years.
- Warm in cool weather - it lightly insulates your head from the cold.
- Easier to personalize with a hatband that changes the look without changing the hat.
- Resistant to rubbing and minor impacts.
Its limits :
- Hot in summer - uncomfortable above 25°C if you’re active.
- Sensitive to heavy rain - felt can warp if it gets soaked. Light drizzle is fine, but avoid downpours.
- Heavier than straw - noticeable after several hours of wear.
Felt by quality : many hats use an X system to rate felt quality. The higher the number of Xs, the more the felt contains wool or beaver (premium fibers), and the more flexible, dense, and durable it is. A 4X is entry-level felt. A 10X or more is higher-quality felt. Wild Nord hats are generally made with accessible-range felt - solid for festivals or occasional wear, without claiming the quality of a Texas hat maker.
The straw cowboy hat: spring, summer, festival
Straw is the ultimate summer material. Lightweight and breathable, it’s designed to be worn outdoors in the sun. It’s also usually more affordable than quality felt.
Its advantages :
- Lightweight - ideal for full days at a festival.
- Breathability - the open weave of some straw lets air flow through.
- Relaxed aesthetic - perfect for a summer look, brunch, or sitting on a terrace.
- Usually cheaper than felt.
Its limits :
- Structurally fragile - if you step on it, it won’t bounce back. Store it carefully.
- Sensitive to humidity - straw can soften and warp in the rain. Not wearable in bad weather.
- Less versatile - hard to pair with a winter or formal look.
- Doesn’t age well: straw weakens over time, unlike felt which develops a patina.
Types of straw : not all “straw” hats are the same. Shantung straw (a synthetic fiber that imitates natural straw) is the most common and most affordable. Palm leaf is more natural and sturdier. Raffia is light and more artisanal. For festival use, the difference is minor - focus on the crown’s sturdiness rather than the prestige of the fiber.
How to choose based on the occasion
| Occasion | Recommended material |
|---|---|
| Outdoor summer festival | Straw |
| Spring festival (C2C, March) | Light felt |
| Indoor country night | Felt |
| Outdoor summer wedding | Straw or straw felt |
| Fall country concert | Felt |
| Everyday spring look | Straw or light felt |
| Halloween or themed party | Felt (more character) |
The seasonal rule, in short
- October to March : felt. Cold weather, heated indoor venues, and darker outfits call for felt.
- April to September : straw. Heat, festivals, and lighter dresses call for straw.
There are also hybrids - “straw felt” (a blend of straw and felt) that try to cover both seasons. They’re fine for versatile use, but not as effective as each material in its ideal context.
Next up on choosing a western hat - shapes, sizes, colors - our complete guide to choosing your cowboy hat covers every criterion.
Find all our selections in the Wild Nord store and explore the western world at your own pace.
Also worth reading
To go further on this topic, you can also read:
